Rip Gemma You Woyld Have Loved Goodbye Earl

rip gemma you woyld have loved goodbye earl

More Posts from Shiningdyingmoon and Others

2 years ago
They’re Communicating

they’re communicating

3 months ago

Spoilers: Eggers' Nosferatu

There's a lot of debate right now on if Count Orlok represents Ellen's shame/trauma/abuse, or if he represents her repressed erotic desires, and in turn there's debate on whether or not viewers who find the Ellen/Orlok dynamic alluring are "missing the point." Eggers and Lily-Rose Depp have both said in interviews that there's a mutual pull between Ellen and Orlok, and even that there's a love triangle element, but obviously the experience is terrifying for Ellen. How can we reconcile the sexual tension and the horror?

I think the broader theme is that Orlok represents everything in a woman's inner world that men refuse to acknowledge and accept - fear and shame and trauma, yes, but also our appetites . After the prologue, the story starts with Ellen begging Thomas to stay in bed with her; she says "the honeymoon was yet too short" and tries to pull him in and kiss him (obviously trying to start some nuptial bliss). But Thomas is anxious to meet with his boss and get his promotion, because he has a narrative he's going to fulfill: he's going to pay Friedrich back, buy a house, and then start having kids (he and Friedrich touch on this a bit later. Notably, Friedrich discloses Anna's pregnancy to Thomas before Anna has made it public.)

It's the start of Ellen and Thomas' married life and she just wants him to prioritize her sexual desire, but he chooses to focus on his ideal of success, which sets him on this path to confronting Orlok. We know Ellen doesn't care about having a house or fine things and she begs him not to go, but Thomas listens to Herr Knock and Friedrich, who tell him that as a husband he has to provide materially. He ignores Ellen's stated desires, and so fails to provide sexually and emotionally. When Thomas gaslights her about her nightmares and calls them childish fancies, he shuts down her vulnerability, which kills the intimacy she was enjoying in the literal honeymoon phase.

On a related note, there's a defence in here for Aaron Taylor Johnson's performance, which I've seen a few male critics call "over acting." In this story Friedrich represents the masculine ideal of the time, he's a rich business owner with a beautiful wife and kids. Thomas clearly looks up to him and wants to emulate him - he wants to give Ellen the life "she deserves." But Friedrich's elevated masculine status is why he refuses to listen to Ellen's "hysterical, sentimental" worries, he's too rational for all that of course. And his stubborn "rationality" leads to the death of his entire family. Friedrich IS the patriarchal ideal that crumbles when confronted with nuance and uncertainty. Some people see Friedrich and assume that a character like him is meant to come across as dignified, and that Aaron Taylor Johnson is messing up by making him look annoying, but really he is giving a great portrayal of a really common, annoying kind of guy. The kind of guy who melts down and has childish tantrums whenever they lose control of a situation, or their manly skills and values are shown to be irrelevant.

The men in the movie (excluding Professor von Franz) frame Ellen as childish for speaking about her dreams candidly, but their own childishness is revealed when her dreams manifest in the form of Orlok and become unavoidable. Ellen (partially? possessed in the moment by Orlok) tells Thomas how "foolish and like a child" he was in Orlok's castle. In the literal context that's cruel, and obviously that shit was scary as hell, but it hits on Thomas' failure in the metaphorical reading. He was a child playing house: 'I'll be the husband and make money, you be the wife and make babies.' When it came time to confront his wife's inner world and all the scary, traumatized, lustful complexity of it, he was completely inept. The message isn't that Orlok is what Ellen really needs, or that Thomas is a wimp, but he's not a perfect husband either. I think "the point" is that a real healthy marriage with sexual, emotional, and spiritual mutuality is impossible in that society with Thomas/Friedrich's ideals. In that kind of society, a spiritually and sexually potent woman like Ellen ("in heathen times you might have been a Priestess of Isis") will always be caught in a "love triangle" with her husband and her own inner world.

2 years ago
This One I Made Just As A Direct Attack At @mxmaelstrom

this one I made just as a direct attack at @mxmaelstrom

1 month ago

Opie choosing to date Lyla knowing she’s a porn actress and then getting mad that she’s a porn actress. Men.

2 years ago
I Love Him 💕💕

i love him 💕💕

2 years ago

Can someone make an edit where Joey is with Ariana Grande's ponytail? I'm trying to see something

1 month ago

POV : you have been scrolling for the past hour and all you see is SMUT

POV : You Have Been Scrolling For The Past Hour And All You See Is SMUT
POV : You Have Been Scrolling For The Past Hour And All You See Is SMUT
POV : You Have Been Scrolling For The Past Hour And All You See Is SMUT
POV : You Have Been Scrolling For The Past Hour And All You See Is SMUT

Please...life is lot more than fucking🙏🏻

2 years ago
Phoebe Bridgers Photographed By Paul Mescal
Phoebe Bridgers Photographed By Paul Mescal
Phoebe Bridgers Photographed By Paul Mescal

Phoebe Bridgers photographed by Paul Mescal

2 months ago

Man...

I just watched The Bikeriders and I'll say: I have A LOT to talk about this movie, I might go into one of my rants about it and toxic masculinity and just the overall male need for connection and the struggle against hegemonic culture in capitalism

Plus, there's so much depth in Benny's character and his relationship with Johnny and Kathy, and he barely even appears!!!

And Kathy, I love how unromanticized her story was.

Johnny and his desperation to be what Benny was effortless

The Vietnam War and its impact on a subculture as a demonstration of how deep cultural hegemony and capitalism can affect peoples' lives

It's amazing really

Loading...
End of content
No more pages to load
shiningdyingmoon - Untitled
Untitled

252 posts

Explore Tumblr Blog
Search Through Tumblr Tags